SAP Extended Warehouse Management (EWM) vs Manhattan Associates WMS

Warehouse management systems are essential in today's logistics industry to efficiently manage inventory, optimize resources, and streamline operations. Two popular WMS options are SAP Extended Warehouse Management (EWM) and Manhattan Associates WMS. Both systems offer comprehensive warehouse management solutions, but how do they differ? In this article, we'll compare the features, functionality, pricing, scalability, support, implementation timelines, and user reviews of these two systems to help you decide which one is the best fit for your business needs.

Comparing the features of SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS

Both SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS offer robust features for warehouse management. SAP EWM focuses on real-time inventory monitoring, slotting, and cross-docking functionality. Meanwhile, Manhattan Associates WMS offers advanced order management systems and solutions for returns management. Both systems have built-in automation functionalities such as automated data collection, task interleaving, and wave planning.

One key difference between SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS is their approach to customization. SAP EWM offers a highly customizable platform, allowing users to tailor the system to their specific needs. On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS offers a more standardized approach, with pre-built modules that can be configured to fit the user's requirements.

Another factor to consider when comparing these two systems is their scalability. SAP EWM is known for its ability to handle large-scale warehouse operations, making it a popular choice for enterprise-level businesses. Manhattan Associates WMS, on the other hand, is more suited for mid-sized businesses that require a flexible and scalable solution.

Pros and cons of using SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS

One advantage of SAP EWM is its extensive integration capabilities with other SAP modules for a complete enterprise solution. Additionally, it offers a comprehensive mobile app interface for tracking and monitoring warehouse activities in real-time. The downside of SAP EWM is its steep learning curve and the need for highly skilled system administrators and consultants.

On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS comes with easy-to-use and intuitive interfaces coupled with robust data analytics and reporting. However, it may not be the best solution for companies with complex distribution networks or those requiring heavy customization.

Another factor to consider when choosing between SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS is the cost. SAP EWM is known to be a more expensive option, with higher licensing fees and implementation costs. On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS is often considered a more affordable solution, especially for smaller businesses or those with limited budgets. However, it's important to note that the total cost of ownership for either system will depend on various factors such as the size of the warehouse, the number of users, and the level of customization required.

How SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS differ in terms of functionality

SAP EWM provides companies with precise inventory tracking capabilities and optimization, robust workflow management, and integration with other SAP software modules. In contrast, Manhattan Associates WMS emphasizes advanced order management systems, accurate forecasting, and returns management functionality. Both systems offer unique features tailored to specific warehouse management needs.

Another key difference between SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS is their approach to customization. SAP EWM offers a highly customizable platform, allowing companies to tailor the system to their specific needs. On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS offers a more standardized approach, with pre-built modules that can be configured to meet specific requirements.

Additionally, SAP EWM is known for its ability to handle complex supply chain processes, including cross-docking, wave picking, and slotting optimization. Manhattan Associates WMS, on the other hand, is designed to handle high-volume, fast-paced operations, with features such as real-time inventory tracking and automated replenishment.

Understanding the pricing models of SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS

One of the significant considerations when selecting a warehouse management system is cost. SAP EWM is a part of the SAP enterprise suite of products and is available via an annual subscription per user. Meanwhile, Manhattan Associates WMS is available either through a perpetual license with maintenance or a cloud-based subscription license model billed monthly.

It is important to note that the pricing models of SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS differ in terms of their scalability. SAP EWM's pricing model is based on the number of users, which means that the cost increases as the number of users increases. On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS's pricing model is based on the number of transactions, which means that the cost increases as the number of transactions increases.

Another factor to consider when comparing the pricing models of SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS is the level of customization required. SAP EWM is highly customizable, which means that the cost of implementation and maintenance can be higher. In contrast, Manhattan Associates WMS is less customizable, which means that the cost of implementation and maintenance can be lower.

Which system is better for small businesses - SAP EWM or Manhattan Associates WMS?

It depends on the specific needs of the small business. SAP EWM is ideal for small businesses that require advanced inventory tracking and integration with other SAP modules. If your company requires sophisticated order management functionality, Manhattan Associates WMS might be the better option.

Another important factor to consider is the cost of implementation and maintenance. SAP EWM can be more expensive to implement and maintain, as it requires specialized expertise and resources. On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS is known for its user-friendly interface and ease of use, which can result in lower implementation and maintenance costs for small businesses.

Real-world examples of companies using SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS

SAP EWM is commonly used by large enterprises such as Procter & Gamble, Nestle, and Levi's. Meanwhile, Manhattan Associates WMS is used by companies like FedEx, Progressive Logistics, and Yamaha Motor.

Procter & Gamble, a consumer goods company, uses SAP EWM to manage their warehouse operations. With SAP EWM, they are able to optimize their inventory management, reduce errors, and improve their overall supply chain efficiency. Nestle, a food and beverage company, also uses SAP EWM to manage their warehouse operations. They have reported significant improvements in their inventory accuracy and order fulfillment rates since implementing SAP EWM.

On the other hand, FedEx, a global courier delivery services company, uses Manhattan Associates WMS to manage their warehouse operations. With Manhattan Associates WMS, they are able to streamline their warehouse processes, reduce costs, and improve their customer service. Progressive Logistics, a third-party logistics provider, also uses Manhattan Associates WMS to manage their warehouse operations. They have reported improved inventory accuracy and faster order processing times since implementing Manhattan Associates WMS.

Integration capabilities of SAP EWM vs Manhattan Associates WMS

SAP EWM has extensive integration capabilities, given its enterprise-level software suite. It seamlessly integrates with other SAP software modules, including ERP and CRM applications. Manhattan Associates WMS also integrates with other supply chain products like TMS, LMS, and OMS.

However, SAP EWM has an advantage over Manhattan Associates WMS when it comes to integration with third-party systems. SAP EWM has pre-built connectors for popular third-party systems like Salesforce, Oracle, and IBM. This makes it easier for businesses to integrate their existing systems with SAP EWM, without the need for custom development. On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS requires custom development for third-party integrations, which can be time-consuming and expensive.

Scalability differences between SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS

Both SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS are scalable solutions. However, SAP EWM is better suited for large enterprises with complex distribution networks. Meanwhile, Manhattan Associates WMS is a more flexible solution, making it ideal for growing companies looking to expand.

Another key difference between SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS is their approach to customization. SAP EWM offers a high degree of customization, allowing businesses to tailor the solution to their specific needs. On the other hand, Manhattan Associates WMS has a more standardized approach, which can be beneficial for companies that want a quick implementation process.

Additionally, SAP EWM has a more comprehensive set of features, including advanced analytics and reporting capabilities. This makes it a better choice for companies that require in-depth insights into their supply chain operations. Manhattan Associates WMS, on the other hand, has a simpler feature set, which can be easier to use for companies that don't require as much complexity.

Examining the customer support offerings of each system

Both SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS offer excellent customer support options. SAP EWM provides a comprehensive knowledge base, online forums, and expert guidance for users. Meanwhile, Manhattan Associates WMS offers online support resources, phone and email support, and training programs.

However, it is worth noting that SAP EWM's customer support is only available during business hours, while Manhattan Associates WMS offers 24/7 support. This may be a crucial factor for companies that operate around the clock and cannot afford any downtime. Additionally, Manhattan Associates WMS has a dedicated team of support specialists who are trained to handle complex issues and provide personalized solutions to customers.

A detailed breakdown of implementation timelines for SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS

The implementation for both SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS can vary significantly and can take up to several months. SAP EWM implementation may take longer, given its complex integration capabilities. It is also dependent on the company's size, customization, and resources. In contrast, Manhattan Associates WMS can be quicker to implement, given its more straightforward setup and customization options.

Future-proofing your warehouse management system: Which option is better?

Both systems are designed to help future-proof warehouse management operations. SAP EWM offers comprehensive integration capabilities ensuring seamless integration with other SAP enterprise applications, making it ideal for businesses looking for up-to-date operational efficiencies. Manhattan Associates WMS provides flexible and scalable solutions for logistics growth and global expansion.

The impact of COVID-19 on warehouse management systems like SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS

The pandemic has had a significant impact on warehouse management systems such as SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS, with the sudden increase in e-commerce and online orders. Both systems have adapted to this new normal by adding contactless technologies and touch-free systems to their warehouse management systems.

User reviews and ratings for SAP EWM vs Manhattan Associates WMS

User reviews for SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS show high satisfaction rates with the systems' functionality and capabilities. SAP EWM has been rated higher in inventory management and inventory tracking, while Manhattan Associates WMS has been rated higher in order management and returns processing.

Making the final decision: Which system is right for your business?

In conclusion, both SAP EWM and Manhattan Associates WMS offer robust warehouse management solutions with various features and functionalities. Choosing the one that is best for your business depends on your specific needs, logistics requirements, budget, and scalability. Take into consideration user reviews, customer support, and implementation timelines when making your final decision.